The holiday season in Italy brings with it a sweet debate that divides families, friends, and even entire regions: panettone or pandoro? These two iconic Christmas desserts are beloved staples of Italian festivities, but they couldn’t be more different—each with its own passionate following!
While panettone’s rich, fruit-studded interior appeals to some, others swear by the buttery simplicity of pandoro’s golden, star-shaped perfection. This friendly rivalry has become an annual tradition, sparking playful arguments at Christmas tables across Italy.
So, what sets these two treats apart, and why do Italians feel so strongly about their choice? Let’s dive into the sweet details, starting with the key differences between panettone and pandoro, so that you can pick your own side to discuss around the dinner table this holiday season!
What Is the Difference Between Panettone and Pandoro?
Panettone and pandoro are both synonymous with Christmas in Italy, yet they differ significantly in taste, texture, and appearance—making the choice between them a matter of personal preference.
What Is Panettone?
Panettone is a dome-shaped, yeast-leavened cake hailing from Milan. It’s renowned for its airy, brioche-like texture and its delightful mix-ins: candied orange peel, citron, and raisins. These inclusions give panettone a rich, fruity flavor that pairs beautifully with the subtle sweetness of the dough.
Traditional panettone is served in slices and is sometimes toasted lightly to enhance its flavor. For an extra indulgent touch, many Italians enjoy it with a scoop of Nutella—or better yet, a high-quality artisan hazelnut spread such as Baratti & Milano, whose rich, velvety texture elevates the experience!
What Is Pandoro?
Pandoro, originating in Verona, offers a simpler, more buttery experience. Its star-shaped design is as iconic as its soft, golden crumb. Unlike panettone, pandoro contains no fruit or raisins, making it a favorite for those who prefer a pure, unadulterated sweetness. It’s traditionally dusted with powdered sugar to evoke a snowy Alpine peak.
Just like panettone, pandoro can also be paired with Nutella—or its artisanal counterparts—to create a decadent holiday treat. Many also choose to serve with ice cream, making it a popular choice for children.
While panettone wins over fruit lovers, pandoro appeals to those who favor buttery richness. Both, however, are versatile enough to be enjoyed on their own or with creative toppings.
And yes, it’s true: There is a difference between the Nutella you’ll find in Italy and the version available in the U.S., with the Italian variety boasting a smoother texture and more pronounced hazelnut flavor, made with less preservatives and less sugar than its US counterpart—all the more reason to plan your trip to the Bel Paese as a gift to yourself or a loved one this holiday season!
The History of Panettone and Pandoro
The origins of panettone and pandoro are as rich as the flavors they bring to the holiday season, steeped in history and regional pride. Their stories reflect the culinary creativity of Italy and the deep connection between food and culture.
The Story of Panettone
Panettone’s roots trace back to Milan, where legend credits its creation to a 15th-century kitchen mishap. According to the tale, a young scullion named Toni was working in the court of Ludovico il Moro.
When the chef accidentally ruined dessert for a Christmas feast, Toni quickly improvised with the ingredients on hand: flour, sugar, eggs, butter, and dried fruit. The resulting sweet bread was an instant success, earning it the name “pan de Toni,” which evolved into panettone.
While the legend adds a romantic touch, historians believe panettone likely developed as a luxury bread in the Renaissance period. During this time, sugar and dried fruits were expensive commodities, and sweetened breads became symbols of celebration and prosperity.
The Origin of Pandoro
Pandoro, on the other hand, comes from Verona and has roots in the Venetian Republic, a major hub of trade and wealth during the Renaissance.
Its name, which means “golden bread,” reflects its rich yellow hue, achieved with a generous use of eggs and butter. Pandoro was initially a dessert reserved for nobility, with its fine, delicate crumb representing culinary sophistication.
Ingredients of High-Quality Panettone and Pandoro
The secret to a truly memorable panettone or pandoro lies in the quality of its ingredients. While many mass-produced versions are available, a real artisan creation stands apart for its flavor, texture, and purity.
How Panettone and Pandoro Are Made
The making of panettone and pandoro is as much an art as it is a science, especially when it comes to artisanal versions. Both desserts require time, skill, and dedication to achieve their distinct flavors and textures.
The Cultural Tradition of Panettone & Pandoro
In Italy, panettone and pandoro are far more than desserts—they are symbols of togetherness, celebration, and the joy of the holiday season. These iconic sweets hold a cherished place in Italian Christmas traditions, from their presence at festive gatherings to the creative ways they are served.
Panettone and Pandoro Recommendations
If you’re looking to enjoy the finest panettone or pandoro, investing in an artisan-quality version is well worth the cost. In Italy, a handmade loaf from a reputable bakery will typically cost around €35. This price reflects the premium ingredients and craftsmanship that go into creating these holiday masterpieces.
For those who can’t make it to Italy for the holiday season, the good news is that artisan panettone and pandoro can be purchased online and shipped internationally. While this option comes with added costs due to duties and shipping, it allows you to experience the magic of these Italian holiday treats no matter where you are. We recommend the brands Oliveri 1882 or Venchi. Read our Italian-Made Christmas Gift Guide for more ideas if you still have shopping to do for people on your list!
Buon Natale!
Share this post with your favorite italy-loving friend this season to test your knowledge. BE SURE TO SAVE THIS POST FOR LATER!
